[00:00:09]
DOES EVERYBODY HAVE THEIR MICS ON UP THERE? OKAY? MINE'S ON AND IT IS EXACTLY 5 30 MILITARY TIME, SO WE'LL GET STARTED. ACTUALLY, SOME 30 UM AND. START WITH CALLED THE ORDER AND CALL
[1. Call to order and roll call.]
THE ROLL. MR BRANDT. KALINGA. MR HONG. OKAY. NEXT. UM HUM A BORDER IS TO PROVE THE MINUTES[2. Approve the minutes from the July 25, 2022, Board of Zoning Appeals.]
FROM THE JULY 25TH. 2022. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING SOMEWHERE. MR BRENT? YES TO YES, MR HAN? YES. I WILL SAY OKAY. DID YOU DO A SECOND ON THAT ONE? OKAY. THE NEXT THING IS ANYONE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK IF HE WOULD STAND AND RAISE THEIR RIGHT HAND AND BE SWORN IN PLACE. YOU SOLEMNLY SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU'RE ABOUT TO GIVE IS TRUE AND CORRECT AND THAT YOU'RE TESTIFYING OF YOUR OWN FREE WILL. THANK YOU. THANKS. UM. WE'VE GOT A LITTLE BIT OF A CHANGE IN OUR AGENDA. THERE WAS AN APPEAL OF ANY KITTY AND OLD CAT INK ON BROADWAY, WHICH IS, UM THEY'VE WITHDRAWN THEIR APPEAL. SO WE'RE NOT GONNA HEAR THAT TODAY, SO THAT'S OFF[3. Hear the appeal of Jennifer Stachler, P.E., Servants Heart General Contracting, representing the property owner of 1300 Golfview Lane (Parcel #040-015575) for a variance to Section 1135.10 (a) – Residential District Requirements; to exceed the 900sf maximum for an attached garage by 95sf, for a total of 995sf by constructing a garage addition of 384sf.]
THE AGENDA. AND OUR FIRST ITEM OF BUSINESS IS TO HEAR THE APPEAL OF JENNIFER STATLER. IS THAT CORRECT? OKAY SERVANTS, HARD GENERAL CONTRACTING REPRESENTING PROPERTY OWNER OF 1300 GOLF, YOU LANE PARCEL NUMBER 040-01. WE'RE VERY INSTANT SECTION 11 35.10, A.RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT REQUIREMENTS TO EXCEED THE 900 SQUARE FOOT MAXIMUM FOR A TASK GARAGE BY 95 SQUARE FEET FOR A TOTAL OF 995 SQUARE FEET BY CONSTRUCTING A GARAGE EDITION OF 3 84. LIKE THE PRESENT YOUR CASE , PLEASE. UM, AS YOU MENTIONED I'M JENNIFER STOCKER FROM SERVANTS ARE GENERAL CONTRACTING . WE ARE REPRESENTING NICOLE AND CHANDLER MCCULLOUGH, 11 1300 GOLF VIEW LANE, AND THEY'RE LOOKING TO ADD A ADDITIONAL GARAGE. THEY CURRENTLY HAVE 611 SQUARE FEET. AND THEY WILL BE ADDING TO CREATE A TOTAL OF 995 SQUARE FEET. COVERAGE FOR THEIR GARAGE. UM, SIMILAR HOMES IN THE AREA HAVE HAVE THESE ADDITIONAL GARAGES, ONE ADJACENT TO IT HAS AN ADDITION AS WELL. SO UM, IT'S IN KEEPING WITH THE REMAINDER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD. UM AND WILL NOT. IT'S OUR UNDERSTANDING THAT THE THIS ORDINANCE WAS JUST TO PREVENT GARAGES FROM DWARFING OTHER HOMES. SO UM, THAT WILL NOT BE THE CASE IN THIS MATTER. SO ANY QUESTIONS? UM. ARE THERE , LAURA? EXCUSE ME. MISS SCOTT IS, UH, THE OTHER ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS WHERE THEY CONTACTED AND WE HAVE MANY POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE FEEDBACK FROM THEM. YES THEY WERE CONTACTED AND WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY RESPONSES. OKAY, GREAT. MR BRENT ANY QUESTIONS? MR HUNT QUESTIONS. I HAVE NO QUESTIONS. UM SO IF THERE ARE NO FURTHER QUESTIONS I WOULD MOVE THAT WE GRANT THE APPEAL. OF. JENNIFER STATLER, SERVANTS OF THE HEART GENERAL CONTRACTING REPRESENTATIVE PROPER PROPERTY OWNER OF 1300 GOLF USED LANE PARTIAL NUMBER 040-0. FOR A VARIANCE DISSECTION. 11 35 POINT ONE. OH, A RESIDENTIAL. DISTRICT REQUIREMENTS TO EXCEED THE 900 SQUARE FOOT MAXIMUM OF ATTACHED GARAGE BY 95 SQUARE FEET. FOR A TOTAL OF 995 SQUARE FEET. IN THE BY CONSTRUCTING A GARAGE EDITION OF 3 84 SQUARE FEET SECOND. MR BRANDT? YES GO, MR HAN. OKAY YOU'RE THERE IS ONE UM ADDITIONAL, UH, ITEM AND THAT IS THAT CONSTRUCTION BEGIN WITHIN
[00:05:01]
12 MONTHS. THAT'S UPROOT. AND THERE'S ALSO A UM THE CITY COUNCIL CAN REVERSE THE DECISION. SO THERE'S A 21 DAY WE RECOMMEND 21 DAY A WEEK. OTHER THAN THAT, YOU'RE A FIELD HAS BEEN GRANTED. ALRIGHT. SOUNDS GREAT. THANKS VERY MUCH. OKAY? NUMBER THE NEXT ITEM. TO HEAR[5. Hear the appeal of John Justus, property owner at 3474 Reaver Ave., (Parcel #040-003595) for three variances.]
THE APPEAL OF JOHN JUSTICE PROPERTY OWNER OF THAT 34 74. REVERE AVENUE PARTIAL NUMBER 0400035 FOR THREE VARIANCES. UM RELATES TO SECTION 11 37 POINT. 08 TO EXCEED IN THE NEXT MONTH, WE'LL HYPER GARAGE OF EIGHT FT BY ONE. WHAT TOTAL OF 90 FT. NUMBER TWO SECTION 1 35.1. OH, I APPROACH THE REAR YARD SETBACK. TO OUR TWO SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT BY 20 FT. VIRTUAL VS BACK SIX FT SIX INCHES. AND THIRD. AS IT RELATES TO SECTION 11 35.1. OH, THERE'S ONE EIGHT TO CONSTRUCT A TWO CAR METAL GARAGE WITH MATERIALS DIFFERENCE FROM THE MAIN STRUCTURE. OKAY WOULD YOU LIKE TO PRESENT YOUR CASE, PLEASE? SORRY. WHAT I'M DOING IS I'M BUILDING A GARAGE.THE HOME WASN'T EQUIPPED WITH THE GARAGE IN THE FIRST PLACE. MY BROTHER BOUGHT THIS PLACE BACK IN 1961 HAVE IT BUILT AND SINCE THEN, MY, UM. SYSTEM. NO LIVED THERE AND SHE FINALLY MOVED TO THE COUNTRY AND WE JUST SWITCHED HOUSE INSIDE THE BIG HOUSE IN THE COUNTRY. AND I'M OLD AND HER DAUGHTERS TAKING CARE OF THE HOUSE IN THE COUNTRY ANYWAY, I'M TRYING TO BUILD A GARAGE ON THE AIRPORT, OUR CARD AND WINTER TIME SO WE CAN GET IT IN AND OUT OF THEIR VARIANTS I'M REQUESTING IS THE MOST GARAGES NOW ARE NINE FT. YOU YOU BUY THEM THEIR NINE FT. THE OLD DEAR OLD. STATUTE SAYS 80. SO I'M ASKING FOR A VARIANCE OF ONE FT BECAUSE MOST GARAGES ARE BUILT THAT WAY NOWADAYS, AND THIS IS A CONSTRUCTION KIT WHERE THEY COME IN AND PUT THE WHOLE GARAGE UP.
THE HEIGHT VARIANTS IS 12 FT, AND THAT'S WITHIN THE LIMITS. AS FAR AS THE METAL BUILDING. UM I CHECKED AROUND AND. THERE WAS GOOD AS CONSTRUCTED AS ANY BUILDING AROUND AND IT'LL FIT IN WITH THE AREA. I GOT WHITE SIDING ON THE HOUSE TO THE GARAGES GOT WHITE SIDING. IT HAS RED TRIM. I HAVE REDDISH BROWN TRIM, AND I'M GONNA FIX THAT. AS SOON AS I GET THE GARAGE IN. AND I ASSUME THE SETBACK IS THE ENTRY TO THE BACK WAS, UM, MADE BACK IN THE SEVENTIES. AND WHAT I'M TRYING TO DO IS JUST MAKE ROOM FOR THE GARAGE AND I'M ASKING FOR A VARIANCE BECAUSE OF THE SETBACK AND THE LOT IS NOT THAT BIG AND I'M JUST TRYING TO FIT THE GARAGE IN TWO. MAKE IT AESTHETIC FOR THE ENTIRE PROPERTY. I SEE. LOOKS LIKE WHERE I'M NEEDED CONCRETE DRIVEWAY CONNECTING TO CONNECT. EXISTING FROM THE EXISTING DRIVEWAY BACK TO THE DRIVEWAY WILL BE CONCRETE. I GOT BLACK LOT BLACKTOP TO THE BACK OF THE BUILDING WILL BE CONCRETE.
THROUGH THE GARAGE. JUST LAURA, DID YOU CONTACT THE NEIGHBORS AND WE DID WE HEAR FROM ANY OF THEM? YES I DID CONTACT THE NEIGHBORS AND WE DID NOT HEAR FROM ANYONE. CHECK THE BOTH NEIGHBORS ON EITHER SIDE AND NEIGHBORHOOD FINE WITH IT. I DO HAVE A COMMENT ON THIS. MIKE POST. SO WITH THE BUILDING DIVISION ON THE BACK. OF THE LOT, SO YOU'RE GOING TO COME OFF THAT BACK LOT? HOW FAR ON THE BACK OF A HALF. OKAY THE ONLY THING THAT'S NOT SHOWN ON YOUR SITE PLANNING. THERE'S ANY EASEMENTS FOR UTILITIES THAT ARE BACK THERE, WHETHER THEY BE OVERHEAD OR UNDERGROUND. OR EVEN A SEWER. AH! EASEMENT OR ANYTHING ON THAT, AND THAT'S SOMETHING WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO DETERMINE BECAUSE WE CAN'T GIVE A VARIANCE. FOR ANY OF THOSE ITEMS, SO AS WE MOVE THROUGH THAT BUILDING PERMIT PROCESS WILL HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE ISN'T BECAUSE, LIKE I SAY THIS BOARD CANNOT GRANT THE VARIANTS. IF THERE ARE EASEMENTS
[00:10:03]
THAT ARE BACK THERE. THEY CAN ISSUE VARIANCES FOR THE ZONING CODE ONLY, AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE HERE TO DO TODAY. THANK YOU. QUESTIONS. THEY'RE REVIEWED THE FILE AND THE DRAWINGS, ETCETERA.SO WOULD LIKE TO DO IS PROPOSAL . WE APPROVED THE APPEAL OF JOHN JUSTICE PROPERTY OWNER 34 74.
NEW PERSONAL NUMBER ZERO FOUR ZERO DASH. 00359 FOR THREE VARIANCES FIRST. SECTION 11 37.1 . OH, TO EXCEED THE MAXIMUM THE WALL TYPE OF THE GARAGE. OF EIGHT FT BY ONE FOR A TOTAL OF 99 FT. NUMBER TWO AS IT RELATES TO SECTION 11. 35.1 YES, I THINK ROACH THE BACKYARD SETBACK.
ACTUALLY SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT. BY 20 FT. UNTIL YARD SETBACK AND SIX FT SIX INCHES. AND THE THIRD ITEM IT IS AS IT RELATES TO SECTION 11 35.1. OH, I GUESS A. TO CONSTRUCT THE TWO CAR METAL GARAGE WITH METAL. WITH MATERIALS DIFFERENT FROM THE MAIN STRUCTURE OF THE SECOND.
CHECK THEM. MR BRANDT? YES INGA ? YES OKAY. UM, YOUR VARIANCE HAS BEEN GRANTED WITH ONE STIPULATION OF THAT CONSTRUCTION BEGIN WITHIN THE NEXT 12 MONTHS. AND THEN ALSO, IT'S MR BARROSO SAID. IF THERE'S UH SURE YOU OR WHATEVER GOING THROUGH THERE I UNDERSTAND WOULD BE A PROBLEM.
BUT JUST AS I MENTIONED IN THE PRIOR CASE, THE CITY COUNCIL KNOWLEDGE REVERSED OUR DECISION WITHIN 21 DAYS. SWEET RECOMMENDED 21 DAY WAITING. SO CONGRATULATIONS. WE'VE GRANTED YOUR PARENTS. THANK YOU. THANKS FOR COMING. AND THE THIRD ITEM ON THE AGENDA. NOTICE. YOU'RE
[6. Hear the appeal of Curt Berkemer, Handbuilt Homes, representing the property owner of 1576 Pinnacle Club Dr. (Parcel #040-013770) for a variance to Section 1135.10 (a); Residential District Requirements to exceed the maximum square footage for an attached and detached garage of 900sf by 491.5sf for a total of 1,391.5sf of garage space combined. ]
THE APPEAL OF KURT. NOTHING THERE. HOW DO YOU PRONOUNCE IT? OKAY MURDER HAD BUILT HOMES REPRESENTING PROPERTY OWNER OF 15 75 CLINICAL CLUB DRIVE. PARTIAL NUMBER 040-0. OH, VARIOUS SECTION 11 35.108 WAS MENSCHEL DISTRICT REQUIRING DISTRICT REQUIREMENTS TO EXCEED MAXIMUM SQUARE FOOTAGE. OF AN ATTACHED AND DETACHED GARAGE. 900 SQUARE FEET BY 491. 2.5 SQUARE FEET FOR A TOTAL. 1391.5R CASE, PLEASE. AND IT'S SOMETHING LIKE MY CLIENT PURCHASED THE LOT THERE AND PINNACLE. UM HE'S KIND OF DOWNSIZING LIVED IN THE COUNTRY, SO HE NEEDS A LITTLE BIT EXTRA SPACE AS YOU CAN SEE THE ARCHITECTURAL PLANS THERE. THE DETACHED CARRIAGE GARAGE AND THE HOUSE GARAGE. NOW GO WELL TOGETHER. THERE'S OTHER HOUSES AND PINNACLE, Y ACTUALLY RON COPPER TREES CONSTRUCTION DIVISION, AND I ACTUALLY BUILT A HANDFUL OF HOUSES AND PINNACLE FOR COPPER TREE. HAVE THE LARGER GARAGES IN THEM. IT'LL BE A GOOD FIT FOR PINNACLE. IT'S A BEAUTIFUL HOME. AND I THINK IT WILL BE EVEN FIT FOR THE COMMUNITY. I APPRECIATE YOU GUYS TIME TO HEAR OUR CASE. MISS SCOTT, HAVE WE CONTACTED THE ADJACENT HOMEOWNERS AND WE RECEIVED. ANY RESPONSE IS YES, WE DID SEND LETTERS TO THE ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS, AND WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY RESPONSES. UM DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? MR HAN. I NOTICED THAT YOU'VE ALREADY STARTED CONSTRUCTION, DIDN'T DETACHED GARAGE. WE THEY DUG IT, BUT THEY DIDN'T. OKAY, SO THE PHOTOS ARE. THE OKAY, THERE'S ONE STIPULATION THAT SET CONSTRUCTION BEGIN WITHIN THE NEXT 12 MONTHS, BUT ALREADY BEGUN SO THAT SHOULDN'T BE AN ISSUES AND THEN THE OTHER ITEM IS THAT THE CITY COUNCIL COULD ALSO REVERSE OUR DECISIONS IF THEY WISH. SO I USUALLY MENTIONED THAT ANYONE WITH AN APPEALS SHOULD. 21 DAYS TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY DON'T GET[00:15:07]
THEMSELVES IN THE BLIND. THE RISK IS THERE SO UM OTHER THAN THAT. WE HAVE. OKAY. SHOULD WE QUOTE MAKE A MOTION THAT WE APPROVE THIS VARIANCE? SECONDED. MR BRANDT? YES TO MR HAN. OKAY YOUR GRANDPA IS APPROVED. PROOF YOUR TIME. THANK YOU. YEP. MHM, THE IS THERE ANY NEW BUSINESS?[7. New business]
JOHN WILL NOT BE AT THE MEETING NEXT MONTH, AND I WILL NOT BE AT THE MEETING NEXT MONTH. OKAY IN THE CAPABLE HANDS OF MR BARROSO , SO WE NEED TO KEEP THE TWO OF YOU HEALTHY SO YOU CAN BE HERE.I'LL TRY AND DO THAT. OKAY OKAY . NIGHTS YEAH, TRY NOT TO BUY A TRUCK OR ANYTHING. SO THAT'S 10 O'CLOCK. OKAY SO IF THERE'S NO OTHER FURTHER BUSINESS I'D LIKE TO ADJOURN THE MEETING.
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.